5-Star Hotels in Nantucket

Compare top-rated 5-star hotels in Nantucket-from historic inns to harborfront resorts. Check rates for the Jared Coffin House, White Elephant, & more. Book now.

Check-in
Sat, 08 Aug
Check-out
Sun, 09 Aug
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
We’ll open Booking.com in a new tab for fair comparison.
Check-in
Sat, 08 Aug
-
Check-out
Sun, 09 Aug
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
2Filter & Sort
View map
Check-in
Sat, 08 Aug
-
Check-out
Sun, 09 Aug
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
2Filter & Sort
View map
View map
1-5 out of 5
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
9.0
Perfect56 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Map
545 yd from City Center226 yd from Nantucket Parks and Recreation
Heated PoolsKids' ClubBeach Shuttles
  • Only year-round island hotel
  • Two heated outdoor pools
  • Complimentary beach shuttles
FromUS$ 2 500 /nightSelect
9.3
Perfect154 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Map
652 yd from City Center303 yd from Nantucket Parks and Recreation
Free BikesSpaChildren's Playground
  • Historic harborside hotel since 1920s
  • Award-winning Brant Point Grill
  • Organic spa treatments with views
FromUS$ 803 /nightSelect
9.8
Perfect79 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Map
6.2 mi from City Center3.1 mi from University of Massachusetts
Private BeachTopper's RestaurantComplimentary Bikes
  • AAA Five-Diamond waterfront dining
  • Private access to two beaches
  • Adult-only seaside retreat
FromUS$ 520 /nightSelect
8.8
Great376 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Map
263 yd from City Center195 yd from Nantucket Whaling Museum
Bike RentalsCourtesy CarTap Room
  • Historic Nantucket landmark hotel
  • Complimentary bike rentals
  • On-site Nantucket Tap Room
FromUS$ 135 /nightSelect
Union Street InnBed & Breakfast
9.9
Perfect91 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Map
173 yd from City Center146 yd from Pacific National Bank
Beach ProvisionsFull BreakfastEvening Champagne
  • Only inn with full hot breakfast
  • Complimentary evening champagne service
  • 18th-century historic building charm
FromUS$ 1 089 /nightSelect

Nantucket's five-star hotels blend historic charm with upscale amenities, offering a premium escape for travelers. Expect properties like the 18th-century Jared Coffin House in the town center, with antique furnishings and a 24-hour front desk, or the harborfront White Elephant Hotel, featuring three unique buildings, full-service spa, and seaside dining at Brant Point Grill. These accommodations cater to couples, families, and luxury seekers, with options ranging from bed and breakfasts like the Union Street Inn (just 300 meters from Francis Street Beach) to the adult-only Wauwinet Nantucket with private beach access. Budget-conscious travelers should plan for peak-season rates that reflect the island's exclusivity, while amenities like free Wi-Fi, free parking, and on-site restaurants ensure a seamless stay.

For a tranquil retreat, book the Wauwinet Nantucket, which offers private beach access and tennis courts, or opt for the family-friendly Nantucket Hotel & Resort, with two heated outdoor pools, a fitness center, and a children's program. The Union Street Inn stands out for its 5-star bed and breakfast experience, including an American breakfast and concierge services. All properties are within minutes of Nantucket's Whaling Museum, Brant Point Lighthouse, and Miacomet Golf Course, making them ideal for exploring the island. Highly rated (97-99 on Booking.com), these hotels provide direct access to galleries, ferries, and boutique shops, with the Jared Coffin House and White Elephant Hotel offering walkable proximity to downtown. Check rates now for exclusive deals on these historic stays.