Cape May Luxury Hotels

Compare 3 top-rated luxury hotels in Cape May: oceanfront Icona, historic Wilbraham Mansion, and cozy Red Cottage. Book now for exclusive deals.

Check-in
Mon, 10 Aug
Check-out
Tue, 11 Aug
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
We’ll open Booking.com in a new tab for fair comparison.
Check-in
Mon, 10 Aug
-
Check-out
Tue, 11 Aug
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
2Filter & Sort
View map
Check-in
Mon, 10 Aug
-
Check-out
Tue, 11 Aug
Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
2Filter & Sort
View map
View map
1-3 out of 3
Sort by: high popularity
  • Price: low to high
  • Price: high to low
  • Guest rating: high to low
  • Popularity: high to low
9.0
Perfect691 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Map
288 yd from City Center1003 yd from Cape May Convention Hall
Private BeachHeated PoolBeach Bar
  • Private beach access
  • Free seasonal shuttle
  • Live music at beach bar
FromUS$ 301 /nightSelect
9.6
Perfect17 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Map
1652 yd from City Center488 yd from Cape May Convention Hall
Heated PoolKitchen UnitsConcierge Service
  • Heated seasonal outdoor pool
  • Kitchens with dishwashers in select rooms
  • Complimentary parking and 24-hour desk
FromUS$ 442 /nightSelect
9.1
Perfect156 total reviews
our site & Booking.com
Map
1.2 mi from City Center460 yd from Sea View Park
Indoor PoolAfternoon TeaJacuzzi Tubs
  • Only hotel with indoor heated pool
  • Individually themed Victorian rooms
  • Complimentary afternoon tea service
FromUS$ 348 /nightSelect

Travelers seeking refined accommodations in Cape May can choose from oceanfront resorts, historic mansions, and boutique hotels near the beach. Most luxury properties are concentrated around the Washington Street Mall and Cape May Public Beach, with rates starting at roughly $200 per night and climbing to $500 or more during peak season. Typical amenities include on-site pools, free WiFi, complimentary parking, and in-room features such as balconies, kitchenettes, or spa baths.

The Icona Cape May offers direct beach access and ocean-view balconies, ideal for guests who want the boardwalk steps away. Wilbraham Mansion provides a heated indoor pool and a tranquil front porch, suiting couples or solo travelers who prefer a historic setting. The Red Cottage combines a seasonal outdoor pool with a full spa service and is located a three-minute walk from the beach, making it a strong pick for families seeking a quiet, four-star base. Reserve several months ahead for summer visits, as availability is limited.