Montauk's beachfront hotels line the Atlantic coast from the village center to Star Island and Amagansett. Options range from the 92-rated Beachcomber Resort with its heated outdoor pool and sauna to the Montauk Yacht Club, a 6.5-hectare luxury resort on Lake Montauk featuring three pools, a private beach, and a marina. Budget-conscious travelers can find oceanfront studios at Wavecrest Resort or Montauk Blue Hotel, which includes complimentary beach chairs and umbrellas.
For a wellness-focused stay, Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa offers an ocean-fed seawater pool and full-service spa. Marram provides a screen-free environment with direct beach access, ideal for digital detox. The Surf Club Resort suits families with apartment-style rooms and a 168-meter private beach. Book early for summer weekends; spring and fall offer milder weather and lower rates.