• My bookings1
  • Currency
    USD
    • CurrencyUSD (U.S. dollar)
      Popular currencies
        All currencies
          No currencies found
          Try changing your search

      Hotels in Shelter Island, United States of America

      Search among 2 available hotels and places to stay in Shelter Island.

      Check-in
      Tue, 29 Sept
      Check-out
      Wed, 30 Sept
      Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
      We’ll open Booking.com in a new tab for fair comparison.
      Check-in
      Tue, 29 Sept
      -
      Check-out
      Wed, 30 Sept
      Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
      1Filter & Sort
      View map
      Check-in
      Tue, 29 Sept
      -
      Check-out
      Wed, 30 Sept
      Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
      1Filter & Sort
      View map
      View map
      Hotels
      1-2 out of 2
      Sort by: high popularity
      • Price: low to high
      • Price: high to low
      • Guest rating: high to low
      • Popularity: high to low
      The Pridwin HotelHotel
      8.5
      Great114 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      1.9 mi from City Center
      Private BeachSaltwater PoolFull-Service Spa
      • Private beach with complimentary water sports
      • Historic 1920s charm and renovations
      • Wednesday BBQ night with live music
      FromUS$ 334 /nightSelect
      Sunset BeachHotel
      8.2
      Great34 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      1.5 mi from City Center
      Private BeachFrench RestaurantBike Rentals
      • Private beach for hotel guests
      • Free bicycle rentals for island exploration
      • Pet-friendly with grooming services
      FromUS$ 596 /nightSelect

      Shelter Island hotels essential information

      🏨 Hotels in Shelter Island 2
      👛 Lowest price 334 USD
      ✍️ Hotels Reviews 79