• My bookings1
  • Currency
    USD
    • CurrencyUSD (U.S. dollar)
      Popular currencies
        All currencies
          No currencies found
          Try changing your search

      Put-in-Bay Hotels on a Budget

      Compare 9 top-rated budget hotels in Put-in-Bay with free WiFi, pools, and lake views. Book now for exclusive deals and check rates.

      Check-in
      Wed, 10 Jun
      Check-out
      Thu, 11 Jun
      Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
      We’ll open Booking.com in a new tab for fair comparison.
      Check-in
      Wed, 10 Jun
      -
      Check-out
      Thu, 11 Jun
      Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
      2Filter & Sort
      View map
      Check-in
      Wed, 10 Jun
      -
      Check-out
      Thu, 11 Jun
      Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
      2Filter & Sort
      View map
      View map
      1-9 out of 9
      Sort by: high popularity
      • Price: low to high
      • Price: high to low
      • Guest rating: high to low
      • Popularity: high to low
      Commodore ResortHotel
      5.3
      Needs improvement62 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      125 yd from City Center522 yd from Stonehenge
      Located 72 miles from Toledo Express airport, the Commodore offers a restaurant and a storage for belongings for guests' convenience.
      FromUS$ 122 /nightSelect
      Bayshore Resort Downtown Put-In-Bay IslandHotel
      7.6
      Very good197 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      558 yd from City Center388 yd from Stonehenge
      Featuring 56 rooms with views of the lake, the Bayshore Resort Put-in-Bay is set about 1 miles from Perry's Cave Family Fun Center.
      FromUS$ 275 /nightSelect
      Bay Lodging ResortResort
      7.4
      Very good216 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      392 yd from City Center797 yd from Stonehenge
      Located a 6-minute stroll from Beer Barrel Saloon, the 2-star pet-friendly Bay Lodging Resort Put-in-Bay offers a continental breakfast and features a swimming pool.
      FromUS$ 211 /nightSelect
      Put-In-Bay CondosAparthotel
      8.2
      Great38 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      FromUS$ 240 /nightSelect
      Bird'S Nest ResortBed & Breakfast
      9.1
      Perfect66 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      1.0 mi from City Center1583 yd from Stonehenge
      The 2-star Bird'S Nest Resort features rooms with views of the pool, while a central location provides access to the scenic park "Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial", which is about a 25-minute walk away.
      FromUS$ 111 /nightSelect
      Bodee'S Bungalow Adults Only Couples Only Boutique HotelInn
      9.6
      Perfect122 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      178 yd from City Center659 yd from Stonehenge
      Staying at the Bodee'S Bungalow Adults Only Couples Only Boutique Put-in-Bay, guests can discover the residential area 10 minutes by foot from Perry's Cave.
      FromUS$ 326 /nightSelect
      Islander InnHotel
      8.2
      Great427 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      182 yd from City Center369 yd from Stonehenge
      Guests of the 2-star Islander can relax in a seasonal outdoor pool or benefit from a hot tub and an outdoor swimming pool, while enjoying location around 0.4 miles from Perry's Victory and International Peace Memorial.
      FromUS$ 148 /nightSelect
      Edgewater Hotel And SuitesHotel
      8.6
      Great112 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      207 yd from City Center592 yd from Stonehenge
      Situated around a 6-minute walk from Deleware Avenue Beach, the 2-star Edgewater Hotel And Suites Put-in-Bay offers 10 guest rooms.
      FromUS$ 150 /nightSelect
      Ahoy Inn GuesthouseInn
      9.2
      Perfect236 total reviews
      our site & Booking.com
      Map
      137 yd from City Center610 yd from Stonehenge
      Starve Island is within 1.7 miles of the Ahoy Inn Guesthouse and Chocolate Museum is only 10 minutes' stroll away.
      FromUS$ 253 /nightSelect

      Put-in-Bay offers several budget-friendly hotels for travelers looking to explore Lake Erie's island without overspending. Most cheap hotels in Put-in-Bay provide essential amenities like free WiFi, outdoor pools, and free parking. Expect rates under $150 per night (though peak summer may vary). Many are located near Perry's Cave or downtown area, within 1-2 km of restaurants and attractions. Some budget options include condo-style units with kitchens for self-catering.

      Top-rated budget picks include Bird's Nest Resort (90/100, Superb) with a pool and garden, and Ahoy Inn Guesthouse (92/100, Superb) offering European-style rooms and free parking. For couples, Bodee's Bungalow (96/100, Exceptional) is an adults-only boutique hotel with continental breakfast. Edgewater Hotel and Suites (86/100, Fabulous) features an outdoor pool and on-site restaurant. Islander Inn (82/100, Very Good) offers multiple pools and a hot tub. These hotels provide good value for money on Put-in-Bay island.