Montauk's spa resorts combine laid-back beach culture with serious wellness credentials. At Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, guests enjoy direct beach access, a full-service spa with healing treatments, and an ocean-fed seawater pool-a standout feature that uses natural saltwater for hydrotherapy. The Montauk Yacht Club on Star Island offers a different take, with three pools (including an indoor one), a spa and wellness center, and a marina that serves as the Hamptons' largest, making it ideal for travelers arriving by boat.
Expect to pay premium rates for these waterfront properties, with both resorts positioned on the higher end of Montauk's accommodation market. The Yacht Club's historic villas and rooms feature private patios with Lake Montauk views, while Gurney's provides five dining venues and 16 acres of grounds. For the best value, consider visiting during shoulder seasons (May-June or September-October) when rates drop but amenities remain fully operational. Both properties offer free parking, beachfront access, and family rooms, though the Yacht Club's additional facilities-padel, tennis courts, and a private beach-make it the more activity-focused choice.