• My bookings1
  • Currency
    USD
    • CurrencyUSD (U.S. dollar)
      Popular currencies
        All currencies
          No currencies found
          Try changing your search

      Sanibel Vacation Rentals: Sanibel Island Rentals

      Compare Sanibel Island vacation rentals and Airbnbs near Gulfside Beach, from bikes and private pools to free parking. Check ratings and book your stay

      Check-in
      Tue, 10 Nov
      Check-out
      Wed, 11 Nov
      Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
      Check-in
      Tue, 10 Nov
      -
      Check-out
      Wed, 11 Nov
      Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
      1Filter & Sort
      View map
      Check-in
      Tue, 10 Nov
      -
      Check-out
      Wed, 11 Nov
      Rooms and Guests2 Guests, 1 room
      1Filter & Sort
      View map
      View map
      Hotels
      Vacation rentals
      All types
      Villas (26)
      1-20 out of 28
      Sort by: high popularity
      • Price: low to high
      • Price: high to low
      • Guest rating: high to low
      • Popularity: high to low
      Shell Island Beach ClubApartment
      9.2
      Perfect
      Map
      525 yd from City Center442 yd from Sanibel Lighthouse
      Tennis CourtHot TubBarbecue Facilities
      • Beachfront apartments with private balcony
      • On-site tennis court for guests
      • Fully equipped kitchen in each unit
      FromUS$ 369 /nightSelect
      Palm Retreat - 3Br Cottage At The Palmview Inn Of Sanibel Island With BikesHoliday home
      9.4
      Perfect
      Bikes IncludedPrivate EntranceFull Kitchen
      • Complimentary bikes for guests
      • Short walk to Gulfside Beach
      • Private cottage with full kitchen
      FromUS$ 615 /nightSelect
      Loggerhead Cay #324Holiday home
      8.8
      Great
      4 adults
      2 bedrooms
      3 beds
      Outdoor PoolTennis CourtChildren's Playground
      • On-site tennis and golf
      • Children's playground on site
      • Fully equipped kitchen
      FromUS$ 286 /nightSelect
      Pirates Cove Cottage At Palm View Inn Of Sanibel With BikesHoliday home
      7.7
      Very good
      Bicycle FacilitiesBeach AccessFull Kitchen
      • Bicycle facilities for island exploration
      • Gulfside Beach a 5-minute walk away
      • Spacious holiday home with full kitchen
      FromUS$ 381 /nightSelect
      Loggerhead Cay #434Holiday home
      9.0
      Perfect
      6 adults
      2 bedrooms
      3 beds
      Map
      1.3 mi from City Center1277 yd from Sanibel Chamber of Commerce
      Rooftop PoolBeach AccessTennis Court
      • Rooftop heated pool
      • Beach access and fishing
      • Full kitchen and dining
      FromUS$ 651 /nightSelect
      Caloosa Cottage At Palm View Inn Of Sanibel With BikesHoliday home
      7.2
      Very good
      Bikes IncludedPrivate GardenFull Kitchen
      • Includes complimentary bikes for guests
      • Private cottage with full kitchen
      • 5-minute walk to Gulfside Beach
      FromUS$ 384 /nightSelect
      Grandma Dot'S House- Marina Villa With Pool And BikesHoliday home
      10.0
      Perfect
      Map
      926 yd from City Center754 yd from Sanibel Causeway
      Private PoolBikes AvailablePet Friendly
      • Private pool in villa
      • Complimentary bikes provided
      • Pet-friendly accommodation
      FromUS$ 409 /nightSelect
      Loggerhead Cay 141Holiday home
      10.0
      Perfect
      Map
      1.4 mi from City Center1501 yd from Sanibel Chamber of Commerce
      Outdoor PoolMassageBeach Access
      • Steps from Gulfside Beach
      • On-site massage services
      • Fully equipped kitchen
      Select
      Shell Island Beach Club #5DHoliday home
      6 adults
      2 bedrooms
      2 beds
      Map
      262 yd from City Center705 yd from Sanibel Lighthouse
      Rooftop PoolGolf CourseHot Tub
      • Rooftop heated pool with sea views
      • On-site golf course available
      • Self-catering kitchen with dishwasher
      FromUS$ 431 /nightSelect
      The Hideaway Cottage At Palmview Inn Of SanibelHoliday home
      8.5
      Great
      Map
      1.7 mi from City Center1681 yd from Sanibel Chamber of Commerce
      Private EntranceFull KitchenBeach Access
      • Private cottage with garden access
      • 5-min walk to Gulfside Beach
      • Full kitchen with barbecue
      FromUS$ 209 /nightSelect
      Sanibel Surfside 114Holiday home
      Map
      1.7 mi from City Center1.1 mi from Sanibel Chamber of Commerce
      Heated PoolTennis CourtBBQ Grill
      • Sea views from holiday home
      • Steps from Gulfside Beach
      • Heated outdoor swimming pool
      Select
      Little Palm CottageHoliday home
      Map
      192 yd from City Center1098 yd from Sanibel Lighthouse
      Private BeachKitchenetteBarbecue
      • Private beach access included
      • Kitchenette with washing machine
      • Outdoor barbecue and dining
      Select
      Island Beach Club P2DHoliday home
      Map
      3.7 mi from City Center841 yd from Gulfside Beach
      Heated PoolFishingFull Kitchen
      • Full kitchen with dishwasher
      • On-site fishing activities
      • Heated outdoor pool
      Select
      Tipsy TurtleHoliday home
      Map
      2.6 mi from City Center1073 yd from Gulfside Beach
      Private GardenBarbecue AreaFree Parking
      • Private garden with barbecue area
      • Three-bedroom holiday home layout
      • Beach access within 19-min walk
      FromUS$ 226 /nightSelect
      Sanddollar A301Holiday home
      10.0
      Perfect
      Map
      2.8 mi from City Center894 yd from Gulfside Beach
      Heated poolTennis courtBarbecue
      • Two-bedroom home with kitchen
      • Heated outdoor swimming pool
      • On-site tennis court
      Select
      Villa Sanibel 1AHoliday home
      Map
      3.8 mi from City Center1028 yd from Periwinkle Place Shopping Center
      Tennis CourtGolf CourseBeach Access
      • Steps from Gulfside Beach
      • Sea view garden with barbecue
      • Tennis, golf, fishing on site
      Select
      Sandpiper Beach #405Holiday home
      10.0
      Perfect
      6 adults
      2 bedrooms
      2 beds
      Map
      2.9 mi from City Center570 yd from Gulfside Beach
      Heated PoolGolf CourseTennis Court
      • On-site golf course access
      • Heated outdoor swimming pool
      • Full kitchen with cookware
      Select
      Beachfront, 3 Bikes, Coolcabana & Free GolfHoliday home
      Map
      1.3 mi from City Center1306 yd from Sanibel Chamber of Commerce
      Private PoolTennis CourtBeach Access
      • Direct beachfront access
      • Private pool plus tennis court
      • Free golf and 3 bikes
      Select
      Loggerhead Cay 331Holiday home
      10.0
      Perfect
      Map
      1.3 mi from City Center1376 yd from Sanibel Chamber of Commerce
      Private BeachHeated PoolTennis Court
      • Private beach on site
      • Heated outdoor pool
      • 4-min walk to Gulfside Beach
      Select
      Lighthouse LookoutHoliday home
      Map
      517 yd from City Center1171 yd from Sanibel Causeway
      Private PoolTennis CourtGolf Course
      • Private pool in spacious home
      • Short walk to Gulfside Beach
      • Diverse on-site activities
      FromUS$ 302 /nightSelect
      Show more
      • 1
      • 2

      Sanibel vacation rentals range from cozy cottages to spacious holiday homes, many located steps from Gulfside Beach. Properties like Sanibel Surfside 114 offer two-bedroom layouts with sea views and an outdoor pool, while Grandma Dot's House features a private pool and complimentary bikes for island exploration. Most rentals include free WiFi, fully equipped kitchens, and on-site parking, with guest scores reaching 100 for exceptional stays.

      Budget-friendly options such as Pirates Cove Cottage provide bicycles and garden access starting under $150 per night, while premium stays like Palm Retreat include three bedrooms and a balcony. For best availability, book early for winter months and choose properties near Sanibel Lighthouse or Bailey Matthews Shell Museum. Many rentals offer free cancellation, and Southwest Florida International Airport is 38-50 km away.